Nanocrystals could drive explosive volcanic eruptions


The formation of nanometre-sized crystals can – even in low concentrations – temporarily change the viscosity of magma and lead to violent volcanic eruptions. That is the conclusion of geophysicists in the UK, Germany and France, who say that their research helps to explain how otherwise calm and predictable volcanoes can turn unexpectedly explosive.

There are essentially two types of volcanic eruption: explosive and effusive. In the former, viscous molten rock with a high silica content tends to trap volcanic gases more readily. This increases the pressure on the magma column such that it can ultimately lead to an explosion.

Basaltic magmas, meanwhile, have a low silica content and tend to be runnier. This usually allow gas to escape gently, leading to effusive eruptions that produce lava domes and flows of the kind seen on Hawaii.

This distinction is not clear cut, however, and basaltic magmas can sometimes unexpectedly produce explosive events. This happened at New Zealand’s Mount Tarawera in June 1886, which destroyed ten Māori settlements and killed around 120 people.

Explosive fragmentation

A common explanation for this unexpected explosivity is the growth in molten rock of microlites, which are small crystals ranging in size from 1–100 micron. In sufficient volumes, these can lock up magma flow, leading to explosive fragmentation. This occurs when magma flow switches from being a continuous liquid body containing gas and crystals to a turbulent flow dominated by gases that contain fragments of molten rock.

There is one problem with this theory, however, in that many such unexpected explosions (including Indonesia’s Mount Tambora in 1815 – the most powerful eruption in human history) occurred even though their microlite concentrations were seemingly not at a sufficiently high level of around 30% total volume.

READ MORE  Russia rushes registration of unproven coronavirus vaccine

In a new study, volcanologist Danilo Di Genova of the University of Bristol and colleagues considered the effects of nanolites, which are smaller crystals that are the precursors of microlites. Using scanning electron transmission microscopy and Raman spectroscopy, the team revealed the presence of previously-unidentified nanolites (20–50 nm in size) in ash samples from three low-viscosity eruptions: Italy’s Mount Etna (122 BC); the Colli Albani volcano (about 37,000 years ago); and Mount Tambora.

Rapid cooling

The team then created their own nanolites in the lab by melting and then cooling volcanic rock samples. Synchrotron-based X-ray spectroscopy revealed how nanolites grow under rapid cooling regimes of around 10–20 degrees per second.

This cooling is typical of that experienced by magma that is ascending quickly at metres-per-second speeds. Further experiments with a synthetic magma, alongside modelling, suggest that the after-effect of so-called undercooling (where a magma, unable to solidify thanks to its dissolved water content, rapidly crystallizes once it degasses) provides the ideal scenario for nanolite growth.

Furthermore, the team found that even in low nanolite concentrations of 5% by volume, the spacing between each nanolite can be very small. “It is already accepted that even a low viscosity melt struggles to flow if it becomes locked by a network of crystals, but this usually requires a fraction of well over 30%,” Di Genova explained.

“Nanolites also have a propensity to agglomerate together and form new and larger solid objects. During this process, volcanic liquid remains trapped inside these agglomerates to effectively increase the fraction of solids in the magma.”

Together, he explained, these processes account for how nanolites can increase magma viscosity for a short time as they form – leading to the previously inexplicable “sudden switch in behaviour,” that can cause calm volcanoes “to occasionally present us with a deadly surprise”.

READ MORE  Magnetic reconnection drives mini-jets in blazar

“Nanoparticles suspended in a very low viscosity fluid appear to have a great effect increasing the bulk viscosity of the suspension even at low concentrations – a factor which could, if confirmed for magma viscosity, enhance explosivity during eruptions,” comments Francisco Cáceres, an experimental volcanologist from the Ludwig-Maximilians-University of Munich. He adds, “This work opens a window to new research that needs to be performed on natural magma, in order to test this claim”.

University of Cambridge volcanologist Marie Edmonds adds, “This work will have very important implications for our understanding of basaltic explosive eruptions but also more broadly for magma rheology, nucleation and growth of crystals and bubbles; and the strength of magma under shear.

It will be important in the future to understand whether wet magmas – those containing lots of water, such as in subduction zones – behave in the same way as those in the experiments, which were dry.”

With their initial study complete, the researchers are moving to model the explosive impact of nanolites on real-life low-silica volcanic settings. When travel restrictions lift after the pandemic, they will be hunting for more examples of nanolites in volcanic rock from across the globe.

The research is described in the Science Advances.


Physics World

Journal Reference:

In situ observation of nanolite growth in volcanic melt: A driving force for explosive eruptions

Although gas exsolution is a major driving force behind explosive volcanic eruptions, viscosity is critical in controlling the escape of bubbles and switching between explosive and effusive behavior.

Temperature and composition control melt viscosity, but crystallization above a critical volume (>30 volume %) can lock up the magma, triggering an explosion. Here, we present an alternative to this well-established paradigm by showing how an unexpectedly small volume of nano-sized crystals can cause a disproportionate increase in magma viscosity.

Our in situ observations on a basaltic melt, rheological measurements in an analog system, and modeling demonstrate how just a few volume % of nanolites results in a marked increase in viscosity above the critical value needed for explosive fragmentation, even for a low-viscosity melt. Images of nanolites from low-viscosity explosive eruptions and an experimentally produced basaltic pumice show syn-eruptive growth, possibly nucleating a high bubble number density.

Ominy science editory team

A team of dedicated users that search, fetch and publish research stories for Ominy science.

What do you think??

Enable notifications of new posts    Ok No thanks
Copyright 2020 Ominy science

Content published here is for information purposes alone.